
Audi S5 vs RS5: Which Audi Coupe to Rent in Montreal
Renting the Audi S5 in Montreal costs $299/day while the Audi RS5 runs $400/day, and the right pick comes down to whether 349 hp is enough or you need the RS5's 450 hp and 3.9 second 0-100 time. Both are available with delivery across Greater Montreal, and both are legitimate choices for a weekend on Saint-Laurent or a run up to Tremblant. This is the Audi S5 vs RS5 rental Montreal breakdown, based on what actually matters once you're behind the wheel: money, speed, comfort, and how each car behaves on Montreal's frost-heaved streets.
How Much Does an Audi S5 or RS5 Rental Cost in Montreal?
The S5 rents for $299/day and the RS5 for $400/day, a $101 per day gap. Over a three day weekend that difference is $303, which is real money but not enough to change a trip budget. Both sit at the accessible end of our fleet, far below a Huracán EVO at $1,499/day or an M4 Competition at $599/day.
A few things worth knowing when comparing:
- Audi S5: $299/day, 349 hp, 0-100 in 4.5s
- Audi RS5: $400/day, 450 hp, 0-100 in 3.9s
- Both delivered anywhere in Greater Montreal, from Griffintown to Laval
Which One Is Faster: S5 or RS5?
The RS5 is decisively faster. Its 2.9 litre twin-turbo V6 makes 450 hp against the S5's 349 hp turbocharged six, and that shows up in the 0-100 numbers: 3.9 seconds for the RS5 versus 4.5 seconds for the S5. Both use quattro all-wheel drive, so both launch hard in the wet, but the RS5 pulls harder everywhere in the rev range.
On paper 0.6 seconds sounds modest. In practice it is not. The RS5's extra 101 horses arrive with a sharper exhaust note and stronger mid-range, so highway passes on Highway 15 north that require planning in the S5 are just a firm throttle press in the RS5. For a comparison of what serious power feels like in an Audi, the RS5 is the closest thing in the fleet to the Audi RS6 and its 591 hp before you jump to R8 territory.
Which Is Better for First-Time Sports Car Renters?
The S5 is the better first rental, and it is not close. At $299/day it is one of the cheapest performance cars on our fleet, its power delivery is smooth and predictable, and its ride quality over Montreal's potholes is genuinely good. The quattro system means you never have to think about traction, even on a rainy launch from a light on Boulevard Saint-Laurent.
The RS5 is not punishing by any stretch. The ride is firmer, the throttle is more eager, and the 450 hp rewards commitment. But if you have never driven a performance sedan coupe, the S5 lets you build comfort without the penalty of overcooking a corner. Plenty of renters book the S5 for one trip and return for the RS5 on the next one.
Which One Handles Montreal Streets Better?
The S5, by a margin. Its softer suspension absorbs the frost heaves on Saint-Denis and the patched asphalt on Sainte-Catherine without thumping into the cabin. Ground clearance is adequate for the Plateau and Old Montreal's older approach ramps, and the turning circle is tight enough for the Plateau's narrow blocks.
The RS5 copes fine but you feel more of the road through the shell, which some drivers love and others don't. If your route includes a lot of city crawling and parking garage navigation, the S5 is the less demanding daily companion. If your plan is highway runs to the Laurentians or the Eastern Townships, the RS5's extra stability at triple digit speeds on the 15 or the 10 is worth the firmer ride.
Is the RS5 Worth $101 More Per Day Than the S5?
For most renters, yes, but not for the reason you'd expect. The $101/day premium buys you 101 more horsepower and the 3.9 second 0-100, but it also buys a car that feels special every minute you're in it: the sharper steering, the sound, the aggression in the front end. Renting a car like this is partly about the memory, and the RS5 delivers more of that.
Book the S5 instead if:
- You're stretching a trip to five or more days and want to control cost
- Your passengers care about ride comfort more than acceleration
- It's your first time driving a performance car
- You want the cheapest legitimate German performance rental in the city
- You want 450 hp and the 3.9 second launch
- Your driving is mostly open road, not downtown gridlock
- You're comparing against an M5 Competition at $599/day or an Audi R8 V10 at $899/day and want the sweet spot
For an Audi S5 vs RS5 Rental Montreal Decision, Which Should You Book?
For an Audi S5 vs RS5 rental Montreal choice, book the RS5 if your trip is two days or less and you care about performance, and the S5 if the trip is longer or comfort matters more. The $400/day RS5 is the better enthusiast car; the $299/day S5 is the better all-rounder and the smarter value over multiple days.
There is a third option worth considering for families or groups: the Audi RS6 Avant at $549/day gives you 591 hp with five doors and a huge trunk, the best of both worlds in one package. And if you want to browse the full German lineup, our BMW rental in Montreal and Mercedes rental in Montreal pages cover the competition.
FAQ
How much does it cost to rent an Audi RS5 in Montreal?
The Audi RS5 rents for $400/day with 450 hp and a 0-100 time of 3.9 seconds. Multi-day bookings are available and delivery across Greater Montreal can be arranged through our team.Is the Audi S5 fast enough for a fun rental?
Yes. The S5 makes 349 hp and hits 100 km/h in 4.5 seconds, which is genuinely quick and quicker than most cars on the road. It is the entry point to real German performance driving and costs $299/day.Do I need a special license to rent an S5 or RS5?
No, a standard valid driver's license is all you need for both cars. Renters must meet the minimum age requirement listed on our FAQ page, and a security deposit applies at pickup as explained on our how it works page.Can I take the RS5 from Montreal to Tremblant or Quebec City?
Yes, both the S5 and RS5 are approved for Quebec road trips. The quattro all-wheel drive makes either car a strong pick for the Highway 15 north run to Tremblant, and we have support in Quebec City if your route extends that far.Which Audi rental is the fastest in Montreal?
The Audi R8 V10 PLUS leads the Audi fleet with 640 hp, renting at $1,099/day. Between the two coupes in this comparison, the RS5 at 450 hp and 3.9 seconds to 100 km/h is the quicker and more expensive option at $400/day.Book Your Audi S5 or RS5 Today
Both cars are ready for delivery across Greater Montreal, and our team at Exotic Rentals Montreal will walk you through pickup, deposit, and insurance in minutes. Call 438-809-4417 or message us on WhatsApp to lock in your dates.
Ready to book? Reach us at 438-809-4417 or on WhatsApp at https://wa.me/14388094417 and we will have your Audi ready when you are.