Back to Blog

Toyota GR Supra vs Audi S5: Entry-Level Sports Rental in Montreal

November 22, 2026

The Toyota GR Supra rental in Montreal costs $400/day with 420 hp and a 0-100 km/h time of 3.9 seconds, while the Audi S5 comes in at $299/day with 349 hp and a 0-100 km/h time of 4.5 seconds. That $101/day gap is basically the entry fee for a raw rear-wheel-drive sports car versus a sharp all-wheel-drive everyday performer. This is the Toyota GR Supra vs Audi S5 rental Montreal comparison, with real numbers on both cars and a clear verdict on which one fits your plans.

Toyota GR Supra vs Audi S5 Rental Montreal: How Much Does Each One Cost?

The Supra is $400/day and the S5 is $299/day, so a weekend works out to $800 versus $598 before extras. Both sit at the bottom of our rate sheet, well under cars like the Audi RS5 at $400/day and the BMW M5 Competition at $599/day.

  • Toyota GR Supra: $400/day, 420 hp, 0-100 in 3.9s, rear-wheel drive
  • Audi S5: $299/day, 349 hp, 0-100 in 4.5s, quattro all-wheel drive
If budget is the deciding factor, the S5 saves you about $100 a day without giving up much in daily usability. If the driving itself is the point, the Supra earns its premium every kilometre.

Which One Is Faster in a Straight Line?

The Supra wins, and it is not close in feel. With 420 hp pushing less weight through the rear wheels, it hits 100 km/h in 3.9 seconds. The S5 needs 4.5 seconds with its 349 hp turbocharged V6.

On paper that is a six-tenths gap, but the Supra feels quicker because everything happens on one axle. Throttle response, gearshifts from the ZF eight-speed automatic, and that turbocharged six-cylinder soundtrack all come at you directly. The S5 launches almost as hard off the line because quattro puts power down regardless of the surface, which matters in March when Saint-Luc or the Plateau still has slush on the side streets. Dry pavement in July: the Supra pulls away. Cold, wet, or snowy: the S5 gets moving with zero drama.

Which One Is Better for a Full Day of Montreal Driving?

The S5 is the better all-day car, and that is exactly what it was designed to be. Four doors, real seats in the back, a trunk that swallows weekend bags, and a cabin that is quiet enough for the drive out to Blainville or Laval without shouting at your passengers.

The Supra is a true two-seater. Trunk space is enough for two small bags, nothing more. The ride is stiffer, visibility out the back is limited, and you will feel every expansion joint on the Metropolitan. That is the trade-off for a car that shrinks around you at speed and communicates every bit of what the front tires are doing. For a date night, a photoshoot, or a twisty run up to the Laurentians, it is the right tool. For hauling three friends to a Raptors game, it is not.

Which Car Is More Fun on Back Roads?

The Supra, full stop. Rear-wheel drive, a short wheelbase, and a chassis tuned jointly with BMW's sports car division make it the sharper instrument on a run up Route 329 toward Lac des Sables. Turn-in is immediate, the brakes have real bite, and the chassis rotates exactly as much as you ask.

The S5 is quick and composed without being playful. It grips hard and stays glued, but quattro masks the kind of feedback the Supra hands over for free. Driven fast, the Supra makes you feel like a better driver than you are. The S5 makes you feel safe, which is a different thing entirely. If the point of the rental is the drive itself, rent the Supra.

How Does the Supra Compare to Other Sports Cars in the Fleet?

The Supra is the most affordable dedicated sports car in our fleet, and it hangs with far more expensive machinery in a straight line. Its 420 hp and 3.9-second 0-100 time put it within a tenth of the Porsche 911 Carrera 4 at $649/day, and only half a second behind an Audi R8 V10 at $899/day.

  • Toyota GR Supra: $400/day, 420 hp, 3.9s to 100 km/h
  • Audi S5: $299/day, 349 hp, 4.5s to 100 km/h
  • Audi RS6: $549/day, 591 hp, 3.6s
  • McLaren 600LT: $1,199/day, 592 hp, 2.9s
So the Supra gives you 90 percent of the supercar sprint for less than half the price of a Lamborghini Huracán EVO at $1,499/day. What you give up is exotic presence. Nobody crosses the street for an S5, and the Supra gets attention without screaming for it.

Which Interior and Tech Do You Get?

The S5 wins on cabin quality. Audi's virtual cockpit, solid materials, and proper rear doors make it feel like a $70,000 car, which it is. Heated seats, excellent air conditioning for July humidity, and a ride that stays quiet at 110 on the 20.

The Supra's cabin is driver-first and a bit narrower in its focus. You get a solid infotainment setup with Apple CarPlay, supportive sport buckets, and a heads-up display, but no rear seats and a lower roof line. Sound insulation is weaker, partly because Toyota wants you to hear that straight-six. Some people call that a flaw. We call it the point.

Which One Should You Rent?

Rent the Supra if the drive is the destination: a solo trip or a two-person weekend where the fun lives in gear changes and back-road apexes at $400/day. Rent the S5 at $299/day if you need practicality wrapped around a genuinely quick car: city driving, passengers, luggage, and an easy 300 km day without fatigue.

A simple rule: if the trip plans revolve around the car, take the Supra. If the car supports the trip, take the S5. Both are bookable right now, and the full range from city cars to McLaren is on our fleet page. Our team can walk you through the difference in two minutes on the phone, or check the FAQ for insurance, deposit, and age requirements before you call.

FAQ

How much does it cost to rent a Toyota GR Supra in Montreal?

The Supra rents for $400/day with 420 hp and a 3.9-second 0-100 km/h time. A two-day weekend runs $800, and multi-day rates bring the daily cost down.

How much does it cost to rent an Audi S5 in Montreal?

The Audi S5 is $299/day with 349 hp and a 4.5-second 0-100 km/h time. It is one of the cheapest genuinely quick cars on our board.

Is the Toyota GR Supra faster than the Audi S5?

Yes. The Supra does 0-100 km/h in 3.9 seconds against 4.5 for the S5, and it pulls harder once moving thanks to its 420 hp six-cylinder. The S5 launches better in rain and snow because of quattro.

Can I rent either car with delivery in Montreal?

Yes, we deliver across Greater Montreal, including Laval, Longueuil, and Brossard. Delivery windows are arranged when you book by phone, WhatsApp, or through the contact form.

Which car is better for a photoshoot or event?

The Supra turns more heads thanks to its aggressive design and low stance. The S5 suits corporate settings better because it reads as premium rather than sporty.

The simplest way to settle the Toyota GR Supra vs Audi S5 question is to pick your dates and lock one in: call us at 438-809-4417 or message us on WhatsApp and both cars can be ready quickly.