Back to Blog

Toyota GR Supra vs BMW M4 Competition: Related Rivals in Montreal

November 22, 2026

The Toyota GR Supra vs BMW M4 Competition rental Montreal debate comes down to $400/day versus $599/day at our fleet, with 420 hp against 503 hp and near-identical 0-100 times of 3.9s and 3.8s. The Supra is the cheaper, lighter, purely.driver-focused pick. The M4 Competition adds two rear doors, real back seats, and more power everywhere in the rev range. Here is how they actually compare once you take delivery on our side of the island.

How Much Does a Toyota GR Supra vs BMW M4 Competition Rental Cost in Montreal?

The Toyota GR Supra rents for $400/day and the BMW M4 Competition for $599/day, a $200 daily gap that adds up fast on a five day rental. The KITH edition of the M4 Competition, which nobody else in Quebec has, runs $649/day with the same 503 hp drivetrain but a collab-ready exterior.

If you want to split the difference, the Toyota GR Supra is the single best value in our entire fleet. Nothing else under $500/day gets you a 3.9s 0-100 sprint and a chassis tuned on the Nurburgring. The BMW M4 Competition costs more because you are paying for 503 hp, an M differential, and the practicality of a two door coupe that still seats four in a pinch.

Both models require the same booking process: valid driver's licence held for at least two years, a security deposit, and proof of insurance. Full pricing and requirements are laid out on our how it works page.

Is the GR Supra Really a BMW Under the Skin?

Yes, and it changes the way you think about this comparison. The fifth generation Supra shares its 3.0L turbocharged inline six, its ZF 8-speed automatic, and much of its chassis hardware with BMW components.

  • 3.0L turbo inline six in the Supra, related to the BMW B58 family
  • BMW-sourced 8-speed automatic in both cars
  • Supra makes 420 hp, the M4 Competition makes 503 hp from its S58 twin-turbo 3.0L
  • Tuning and chassis development stayed Japanese for the Supra, German M-style for the M4
So the "rivalry" is really a family argument. The Supra takes BMW hardware and gives it a shorter wheelbase, a lower center of gravity, and a suspension tune that feels sharper on Montreal's patchwork pavement. The M4 takes the same idea and adds thrust, a limited-slip-style M differential, and everyday usability.

Which Is Faster in a Straight Line?

They are closer than the horsepower numbers suggest. The M4 Competition does 0-100 in 3.8s and the Supra does it in 3.9s, a tenth of a second you will never feel from the driver's seat.

The difference shows up past 150 km/h, where the M4's extra 83 hp and higher tuning keep pulling. On a Circuit Gilles Villeneuve-style straight or a run up Highway 13, the M4 wins. In city driving, and let's be honest, that is most of your Montreal rental, both cars rocket from light to light identically. Launch control works well in both. The Supra's shorter gearing actually makes it feel more urgent from 0 to 60.

Which One Is Better for Montreal Streets and Parking?

The Supra wins on size, the M4 wins on space. The Supra is a two-seater with a small trunk, which matters if you are doing airport pickups at YUL or lugging golf bags out to Blainville. The M4 Competition is a coupe with genuine rear seats and a usable trunk.

Consider your itinerary. A coupe run down Chemin de la Côte-des-Neiges, over to the Plateau, and up to Mont-Royal for the view? Supra, no contest, it is narrower and easier to park on Saint-Denis. A weekend to Sherbrooke or Quebec City with a passenger's luggage? The M4 breathes better on the highway and swallows two weekend bags without drama. Winter and spring potholes also punish low cars, and both of these sit low, but the Supra's shorter overhangs help.

Which Rival Gives You More Driving Emotion?

The Supra gives you more analog feedback, the M4 gives you more raw performance. The Supra's steering is quicker, its body is more compact, and you feel every weight transfer in a way that makes even Atwater Boulevard fun. The M4 answers with torque that arrives like a wave and an exhaust note on cold start that wakes up the whole block in Old Montreal.

If your trip is about the car itself, the Supra is the purist pick. If the car is the soundtrack to a bigger trip, concerts, client dinners, a photo shoot, the M4's presence and space make it the better tool. Some clients book both, one for a city day and one for a highway day, since the total for a day of each comes to about $999 with the standard M4.

When Should You Step Up to Something Else Entirely?

If the $599 M4 Competition price already fits your budget, two alternatives deserve a look before you book. The Audi RS6 at $549/day gives you 591 hp, all-wheel drive, and a wagon body that out-hustles both rivals in bad weather. The BMW M5 Competition at $599/day matches the M4's price and jumps to 617 hp with four doors.

And if you came here because you wanted a coupe with maximum theatre for the least money, the Audi R8 V10 at $899/day and 562 hp is the next real step up, a naturally aspirated V10 you cannot get from either Japanese or German rivals in this comparison.

The Verdict: Book the GR Supra or the M4 Competition?

Book the Supra at $400/day if you want the sharpest steering, the smallest footprint, and the best price-per-thrill in Montreal. Book the M4 Competition at $599/day if you want 503 hp, rear seats that exist, and the stronger highway car for runs to Gatineau or Trois-Rivières. Both are available now for delivery across Greater Montreal, from Griffintown to Longueuil.

FAQ

How much does it cost to rent a Toyota GR Supra in Montreal?

The Toyota GR Supra rents for $400/day with 420 hp and a 0-100 time of 3.9s. A security deposit and a licence held for at least two years are required at pickup.

How much does it cost to rent a BMW M4 Competition in Montreal?

The standard BMW M4 Competition rents for $599/day and the KITH edition for $649/day. Both produce 503 hp and sprint from 0 to 100 in 3.8s.

Is the Toyota Supra faster than the BMW M4 Competition?

Barely distinguishable, the Supra does 0-100 in 3.9s against the M4's 3.8s. The M4 pulls ahead at higher speeds thanks to 503 hp versus 420 hp.

Can I rent a Supra or an M4 Competition with a regular driver's licence?

Yes, a standard full licence held for two years or more is enough for both models. There is no special permit requirement for either car.

Can the Supra and M4 be delivered outside Montreal?

Yes, we deliver across Greater Montreal and to cities like Laval, Brossard, and Repentigny. Contact us in advance so delivery logistics are arranged on time.

Ready to lock in the Supra, the M4 Competition, or both, call us at 438-809-4417 or message us on WhatsApp at https://wa.me/14388094417 and we will handle delivery to your door.